Search This Blog

Monday, September 5, 2016

dalit is right enough

On July 11, 2016, a video of cow vigilantes mercilessly beating up seven Dalit men for skinning a dead cow in Una district, Gujarat, came to light. In protest against the incident, many Dalits have refused to handle cow carcasses(body,शवो). The gau rakshaks should be happy, but they are not. Non-Dalits, presumably including gau rakshaks, have retaliated(react,प्रतिकार) with more violence against Dalits — this time for not picking up cow carcasses — in Samter (August 16), Bhavra (August 20) and Rajkot (August 24), all in Gujarat.
Herein lies the Dalit dilemma(doubt,दुविधा) — he is damned if he does and he is damned if he doesn’t.
The bane of Hindu society is varna, the four-tier arrangement said to be sanctified(holy,पवित्र) by the scriptures. The arrangement encompassed the majority and assigned them places, but it also excluded a large number. The excluded were the outcasts or the untouchables. Inequality by birth was the basis of the arrangement. That inequality stayed with you throughout your life. Violence against Dalits is the punishment for disobeying the rules of the arrangement. Rohith Vemula summed it up: “My birth is my fatal accident.”
×
The Dalit Mobilisation
The Dalits have decided that enough is enough. They have decided to mobilise. The scale of social mobilisation of Dalits in Gujarat and Maharashtra, and to some extent in other parts of the country, has not been seen in recent times. Although much of the media is not covering them, massive rallies and marches are being held. There is palpable(clear,स्पस्थ)anger in the community because of the sense of impunity(free from blame,दंडमुक्ति) with which they are being subjected to violence in certain parts of the country. According to the National Commission for Scheduled Castes, in 2015, Gujarat reported the highest crime rate against Dalits, followed by Chhattisgarh and Rajasthan.
Dalits are angry about the hollowness(falseness,खोखलापन) of the current hyper-nationalism where everything about India is called great and every criticism is labelled as anti-national. They are angry about the way the Una incident and other such incidents are being dismissed as isolated or as conspiracies. It is noteworthy that the boycott of cow carcasses, the rallies and the marches have happened through social, not political, mobilisation.
After a long period of silence, the Prime Minister spoke on August 6. He said, “I get so angry at those who are into the gau rakshak business… I have seen that some people are into crimes all night and wear the garb of gau rakshaks in the day.” The very next day, at a rally, he said, “You can shoot me rather than target the Dalits.” This is a strange statement for a Prime Minister: he should use the enormous(big,बड़ा) powers of his office to punish the perpetrators(criminal,अपराधी) of violence.

Change Agonisingly(painful,पीड़ाजनक) Slow

Change is taking place, but it is agonisingly slow. In urban areas, where economic and professional identities usually take precedence(priority,तरजीह), and in parts of India where social movements have brought about change, a majority of Hindus do not feel passionate about the caste order. Many Hindus may still prefer marriages within the caste, but have friends among Dalits. Many may express angst about the reservation system, but do not begrudge(envy,ईर्ष्या) the limited preference to Dalits in educational institutions and in some jobs.
However, there is a section of Hindu society that continues to look back with nostalgia(regret,खिन्नता) at the days of caste domination. Many of them have read a sign of approval in the BJP’s victory in 2014. The cow vigilantes are the latest manifestation of centuries of a supremacist ideology. The flurry of bans on cow slaughter and beef consumption, and the aggressive majoritarian narrative, have given them fresh wind.
Few people saw the casteist agenda more clearly than Dr Ambedkar and ‘Periyar’ E V Ramasamy. Both were pessimistic(negative,निराशावादी) about the reformation of Hindu society. Dr Ambedkar did not think that Dalits could find dignity within the fold of the Hindu religion and urged(forced,मजबूर) them to convert to Buddhism. Periyar’s way was atheism and rationalism. The third way is reform of the Hindu social order and accelerating the trends that will usher(show,दिखाना) in a new social order — education, industrialisation, urbanisation, communication and technological advance.

The Constitutional Goal

For the Hindu hyper-nationalists, the idea of a ‘Hindu’ nation is superior to the idea of a constitutional democratic republic. They will sweep the pains of caste history under the carpet. They think that to uphold the idea of a ‘Hindu’ nation it is necessary to underplay its flaws and hide the price that is paid by millions of Dalits and the minorities. On the other hand, the Constitution-makers did not deny the existence of these problems: they acknowledged the prevalence(spreading,प्रसार) of caste differences and discrimination(unfair,भेदभाव) and formulated what they believed would be intermediate solutions, such as reservation for the Scheduled Castes and rights of minorities.
The real focus of the Constitution is to secure a set of natural rights that every Indian should enjoy, irrespective of the historical injustices. It is to make caste, religion and gender irrelevant to citizenship and citizens’ rights.
The project of creating this sense of equal citizenship is still a work-in-progress in this vast and complex land. Hindu hyper-nationalism, which is a form of majoritarianism, is at odds with the constitutional project. The conflict(battle,विवाद) is playing out, in an increasingly violent manner, before our eyes. The consequences(result,परिणाम) of a long-drawn conflict will be terrible for the country and its progress toward the goal of a peaceful and prosperous nation.



courtesy:indian express

Sunday, September 4, 2016

DOWNLOAD MONTHLY PDF OF AUGUST

 Now you can download monthly pdf of AUGUSTmonth.these articles are not only for english but also it will expand your current affairs.this ebook also contains exclusive articles from know your english.




number of articles-30

file format-pdf

price-25/- only



download now:AUGUST





A city is for all its citizens


“Universal” is a tricky word. It has an enormous(large,विशाल) appeal, an unquestioned romance of taking everyone along. Universal human rights, universal access to basic services, housing for all. It is the barometer of inclusion done right. The dark side of the romance is that it’s one of the hardest things to achieve. Often the “universal” is a vanishing(disappear,गायब) horizon and, like all horizons, the mirage is what makes you lose sight of the very real trade-offs and constraints in your way.
This week the Delhi Jal Board (DJB) announced a new horizon towards the idea of universal access to a basic urban service and human need: water. The “Jal Adhikar Connection” (a Right to Water Connection) promises to let households within slums in Delhi apply for legal, metered water connections “irrespective of the status of their residence.” This move — following the Government of Delhi’s already given pledge(promise,वादा) to extend water and sanitation services to unauthorised colonies — implies that legal, public and metered water could (like electricity) actually cover the city as it exists rather than as it is imagined in plans and laws.
The city is what it is

It is critical to emphasise how important this is. In Indian cities, one of the biggest blocks to any imagination of “universal” or “inclusive” development is not lack of money, land or technology as is so often imagined. It is that a large number of our fellow urban residents are not considered urban residents at all — they are not part of the “universe” to be reached. The grounds of their exclusion are particular to the way our cities have been built. For multiple reasons, Indian cities are largely auto-constructed. Put simply: they have been built not by the intentions of planners or architects but by people themselves. From the slum to the unauthorised colony, the historical urban village trying to change its identity to the new peri-urban development, each neighbourhood has some kind of tension with law and planning. In Delhi’s last reliable statistic on this in 2000, only 24 per cent of the city lived in a “planned colony.” Everyone else, nearly three-fourths of the city, lived or lives some distance from this legal and planned norm. It is now well argued that this “illegality” is not one most of these residents perform to seek personal gains; it is simply the only way in the context of state and market failures to find a way to make life in the city. As activists have long argued: when three-fourths of a people find themselves violating law, it is the law itself that is broken.
“Spatial illegality” has been a critical — and deeply under-recognised — part of what has broken the possibility of universal access to basic services in our cities. As the rules have changed over time, utilities like the DJB have been, at worst, prohibited from giving legal water connections in “illegal” slums and “unauthorised” colonies, or, at best, such provision has been left to discretion(sense,विवेक), the dreaded(fearful,भयानक) “may” rather than “shall” of public policy. In multiple legal challenges, courts have refused to acknowledge the urban right to water citing spatial illegality even if this leaves the basic needs of thousands unmet, their dignity denied.
The irony is that even those who defend such exclusions do not fully realise the cost they themselves pay for them. Partly as a result of spatial illegality, our city’s infrastructure is not a network or a system. It is a set of fragmented(break,खंडित)splinters. It struggles to move to its horizon, reaching one colony but bypassing the other, reaching one now and making the other wait, trying to navigate a geography not of demand and supply but of varied degrees of legality and legitimacy. Who gets infrastructure and when thus become matters of power and patronage, reproducing social inequalities in the space of the city.
Not only does this mean that rights and entitlements are conditioned on where you live in the city, it also means that DJB chief Kapil Mishra is absolutely right when he says that without expanding access more “universally,” the DJB can build neither a scientific system nor an efficient one. Infrastructure systems are just that: systems. They need scale and connectivity to be economically viable and technically sound. The DJB’s financial health and self-sufficiency will gain enormously when thousands of new households give revenue to the public utility instead of to tankers and private suppliers. Its pipelines will map, connect and function — their geographies seeking to reach rather than bypass, connect rather than fragment. Wastage will reduce, efficiencies will rise. There are good models to learn from here. When the Bangalore Water Supply and Sewerage Board introduced a category of “shared taps” to precisely(clearly,स्पस्थ्तया) open up water connections into slums, it saw its financial health improve alongside the improvements in the city’s overall indicators of health, work, housing quality and poverty. When Ahmedabad gave networked infrastructure to its slums, overall indicators of access slowly rose for the city as a whole.
Yet herein lies the first danger of taking an important move and losing ourselves in a mirage well before the horizon is near. Technical and economic efficiency are necessary and pivotal(crucial,निर्णायक) reasons to want to make access to water universal but are not, they must not be, sufficient ones. In an auto-constructed city where spatial illegality breaks access to basic rights, expanding the right to water must be a part of a larger effort to expand the right to the city itself.
The city planner’s public

Ambedkar once said that a Hindu’s public is just his caste. An Indian city’s public is too often just the legal, planned colony. The graded inequalities that follow between this imagined ideal and all other ways of inhabiting the city are real. The exclusions are simultaneously socially performed, legally enshrined, and economically reproduced. Recognising the right to water — it is a jal adhikar connection — must be the first step in taking on the spatial illegality that urban residents have been forced into and then held accountable for. It must begin to return to the Indian city its actual universal, its actual publics, to all of its residents. For this, we must begin at the most fundamental of all claims: to be recognised as being in the city, to be acknowledged, and to be valued as workers, citizens and bearers of rights rather than just the “poor,” “slum dwellers” or “encroachers.” What Delhi must do now is to stand by its Jal Board that has taken a first and important step to live up to being and becoming a truly public utility.

courtesy:the hindu

Saturday, September 3, 2016

The Roll-out Challenge

Canada’s Constitution explicitly(clearly,स्पस्थ्तया) mandates the free flow of goods and services within the vast country. But its bureaucracy has devised ways of slowing down internal trade by creating the need for licenses and permits from every municipality and utility company. According to the Canadian Senate’s Banking Committee, the annual losses from internal trade barriers is approximately $99 billion. The cost of trade barriers in India could turn out to be equally shocking.
There is a near unanimity(full agreement,मतैक्य) on the potential of GST as a gamechanger. On the one hand the government is encouraging enterprise through initiatives like Make in India, Start-up India and a focus on improving “ease of doing business” and on the other hand it is bringing in changes in labour laws, the direct tax code to replace the archaic(old,पुराना) Income Tax Act of 1961 and a new bankruptcy law to protect the interests of key stakeholders.
The current labyrinthine(complex,जटिल) tax structure is an important reason why logistics costs in India, at around 14 per cent of the value of goods, are among the most expensive in the world. Trucks are idle for about 40 per cent of the time — queuing up, filling forms and paying CST and octroi at numerous(many,बहुत से) check-posts. A check-post free movement can bring down the transportation time and cost by 30 per cent and 20 per cent respectively. In practice, however, this may be wishful thinking. Since there are a number of goods that are outside the GST — sin goods, for example — check-posts will continue at least at state borders. Moreover, the state transport departments will continue to have check-posts for non-tax checks like vehicle registrations and road permits. Coordination between the transport departments across states could be an innovative way forward. The use of technology will be imperative(obligatory,अनिवार्य) in facilitating information flow between the states. Smart tags and scanners could alleviate(reduce,कम) some of the pain. The true gains of the GST will be realised only if there is a seamless movement of goods and services amongst states.
×
The GST Network is the most critical component in ensuring successful implementation of the GST. It will facilitate online registration, GST credits, tax payment and return filing seamlessly amongst multiple stakeholders. “Blockchain” technology offers a historic opportunity to develop a GSTN based on “distributed ledgers”, in a true spirit of cooperative federalism.
The April 2017 deadline set for the rollout of GST is going to be challenging. The GST Council has to be formed within 60 days of the Presidential assent to the bill, it has to agree and make recommendations on modern GST laws and rates. The states have to pass their own legislations. The endless bargaining of large versus small, consuming versus producing states, and the ever elusive(deceptive,भ्रामक) RNR will be gigantic(huge,विशाल) stumbling blocks. The GST council is an interesting innovation with veto powers to both the Centre and collectively to the states. The centre has one-third and all the state governments have two-thirds weight and decisions have to be taken with at least three-fourths majority. So dogmatically(clearly,स्पस्थ रूप से), states can never reach the magic figure of 75 per cent without the Centre’s help and similarly, the Centre needs the support of at least 19 states. Interestingly, the BJP and its allies have governments in 15 states. However, the GST council only has recommendatory powers, it cannot override the states’ right to set taxes given in the Constitution.
GST provides a chance to draft a modern law aligned with the technological advancements of the 21st century. The tax administration has to implement a truly modern tax law, the foundation of which, unlike earlier ones, is laid on trust.
The PM’s clarion(loud,बिगुल) call that the GST will end “tax terrorism” will be realised only if a “consumer first” strategy with a strong dose of technology is made central to the implementation plan. Otherwise, “one country, one tax, one market” could remain an unrealised dream.


courtesy:indian express

Friday, September 2, 2016

Weighing the burden of proof

 “An honest civil servant should not be harassed by anybody or agency or institution while in service or after retirement. It would make the civil servants working in the system nervous and edgy, which would not be in the interest of the country,” Sanjay Bhoosreddy, Honorary Secretary of the Central IAS Officers Association has said.
Ponderous(burdensome,कष्टकारक) words indeed in the context of former Union Coal Secretary H.C. Gupta, who is facing trial in several Coalgate cases, choosing not to have any lawyer to defend him. Mr. Gupta told the trial judge recently that he did not have the money to hire a lawyer. He also turned down an offer of state aid made by the judge. In all likelihood, he will argue his own case. This is an extraordinary decision that could prove to be a double-edged weapon. The skill required to defend an accused in a criminal case is a specialised one. In my view, Mr. Gupta is taking too big a chance out of desperation and disgust at the way things are taking shape around him.
Appeal to good senses

Mr. Gupta is obviously outraged(angry,
गुस्सा) at the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) action. He probably understands that the law on the subject is against him, and he would therefore appeal directly to the good senses of the judge, something bordering on an attempt to play on emotions. Not for him the technicalities of what he is accused of. In his own eyes, he has done nothing wrong, and cannot be placed in the company of the corrupt and wily. He is only partly right.
Many in government and outside may dismiss him as a maverick(unorthodox,अपरंपरागत). From whatever I have heard of him, Mr. Gupta was an outstanding officer with a reputation for integrity. Remember also that the formal charge sheet against him by the CBI do not allege that he ever obtained any gratification for showing favour to the private companies that had received licences to operate a few coal mines. The charge sheet indicts him only as part of a ‘conspiracy’ to confer undue favour on private parties, and which caused loss to the public exchequer. This implied that he was negligent(careless,लापरवाह), and there was no application of mind on his part when the screening committee headed by him decided to examine the licence applications in question. There is no recorded evidence, however, that hedissented(disagreement,असहमति) from the majority opinion which favoured the grant of licences to some firms.
The conclusions of his committee were purely recommendatory in nature. That the final authority here was the Coal Minister, who, at that point of time, was Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, and that he was not prosecuted by the investigating agency, is not very relevant to Mr. Gupta’s defence — although the CBI decision, possibly backed by legal opinion, smacked of double standards. Remember, in Bofors, Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi figured posthumously in the charge sheet as ‘accused not sent for trial’ only because he held charge of Defence. There was no charge that Bofors made any payment to him. Interestingly, what many of us would look upon as a moral or constructive civil liability comes to be defined as ‘criminal misconduct’ under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, which was enacted to lend more deterrence(obstacle,अवरोध) to what was being considered for long as a weak and toothless — the 1947 law against public servant corruption.
Element of ‘abuse of office’

Several judgments over the years had exposed the lacunae(lack
,खामिया) in the 1947 Act, which enabled the corrupt to get off scot-free on being given a benefit of the doubt. Significant was the Supreme Court observation inM. Narayanan Nambiar v. State of Kerala, that under Section 5(1) (d) of the 1947 Act, an element of abuse of office was a necessary ingredient while trying to establish that a public servant used corrupt or illegal means to obtain pecuniary(financial,धन संबंधी) benefits. And ‘abuse of office’ was too vague(unclear,अस्पस्थ) an expression that let many corrupt officers off the hook. In several other judgments on the subject, courts had narrowed down the circumstances under which a public servant could be prosecuted for corruption. This is the background to the promulgation of the 1988 Act, which, under Section 13(1) (d), laid down five forms of criminal misconduct by a public servant. Finding that some officers were giving in too easily to corrupt demands from above — and did not do anything to resist such demands under the belief that as long as they were not beneficiaries, no criminal liability was liable to be attached to them — the government decided that such kind of abetment(incite,उकसाना) of graft in high places had to be penalised. This accounts specifically for Section 13(1) (d) (iii), according to which, a public servant commits the offence of criminal misconduct if he, “while holding office as a public servant, obtains for any person any valuable thing or pecuniary advantage without any public interest”.
The tirade of the IAS and several senior servants belonging to other superior services against Section 13(1) (d) (iii) is on the ground that the burden of proof in criminal cases, which normally rests with the prosecution, shifts here to the public servant arraigned by law, and the latter had to prove to the satisfaction of the court that he did not at all benefit from the transaction under probe. This incidentally is germane(relevant,सार्थक) to the defence of H.C. Gupta. This criticism is not true, although on a superficial(external,सतही) reading it appears as if the prosecution had no responsibility at all to establish the guilt of an accused.
Several decisions related to the 1947 Act and expert views on the 1988 Act clarify that court presumption of any accused’s guilt contemplated here is not automatic. Such presumption follows only after the prosecution had done its duty of presenting evidence that the accused had “obtained or (has) agreed to obtain for himself or for any other person gratification (other than legal remuneration)”. Also, Section 20 of the 1988 Act, which deals with the circumstances under which a court can raise a presumption against an accused is specific to habitual offenders and not to others. Besides, the presumption is one of law and not facts. These interpretations alone should allay(reduce,कम) the misgivings and fears of an honest civil servant that he would be hauled up for transparent decisions which stand the risk of going wrong and causing loss to the exchequer.
Amendment before Parliament

An amendment to the PC Act of 1988 is before a select committee in Parliament. It deals with Section 13(1) (d). It is just possible that this subsection may be eventually substantially diluted or wholly deleted. If this happens, the logical question would be one of how to introduce deterrence against a civil servant who, though honest, would like to just drift and permit himself to cave in against a dishonest Minister. This is a serious issue that negates
(invalidate,नकारना) the basic concept of civil service accountability. This would actually promote the tendency of the executive to choose weak civil servants who may be personally honest but are known to be extremely timid(afraid,डरा हुआ), and from whom no resistance at all to dishonest decisions could be expected. The malady(illness,रोग) is particularly prevalent(popular,प्रचलित) in some States where dishonesty is the order of the day.
The popular impression now is that in our country there is no fear of the anti-corruption law on the part of government officials. When this is the hard reality on the ground, concerned citizens would do well to collectively protest against any dilution of anti-corruption safeguards as the proposed amendment seeks to do.
A final word. What is the IAS Officers Association doing to promote integrity among its members? I would like to ask the same question of those holding positions in other associations, such as those for the IPS and IFS. Such groups cannot be mere trade unions fighting for rights. Their obligations include a stout(strong,मजबूत) advocacy of adherence by their members to ethics while serving the public. Whatever I hear on the subject may not however be music to the ears of those who currently stand for probity.
 courtesy:the hindu

Thursday, September 1, 2016

Why the Surrogacy Bill is necessary

Surrogacy is when a woman carries a baby for another couple and gives up the baby at birth. In the past decade, commercial surrogacy has grown tremendously in India. It is currently estimated to be a $2-billion industry. Before November 2015, when the government imposed a ban, foreigners accounted for 80 per cent of surrogacy births in the country. This is because most countries, barring a few such as Russia, Ukraine and some U.S. states, do not permit commercial surrogacy. Many countries in Europe have completely prohibited surrogacy arrangements, both to protect the reproductive health of the surrogate mother as well as the future of the newborn child.
The trigger
The debate began when, in 2008, a Japanese doctor couple commissioned a baby in a small town in Gujarat. The surrogate mother gave birth to a healthy baby girl. By then the couple had separated and the baby was both parentless and stateless, caught between the legal systems of two countries. The child is now in her grandmother’s custody in Japan but has not obtained citizenship, as surrogacy is not legal in Japan.
In 2012, an Australian couple who had twins by surrogacy, arbitrarily(randomly,मनमाने) rejected one and took home the other. A single mother of two from Chennai decided to become a surrogate mother in the hope that the payment would help her start a shop near her house. She delivered a healthy child, but her hopes bore little fruit for herself. She received only about Rs.75,000, with an autorickshaw driver who served as a middleman, taking a 50 per cent cut. After repaying the loans, she did not have adequate(enough,पर्याप्त) money. On January 29, 2014, 26-year-old Yuma Sherpa died in the aftermath(result,परिणाम) of a surgical procedure to harvest eggs from her body, as part of the egg donation programme of a private clinic based in New Delhi.
These incidents highlight the total disregard for the rights of the surrogate mother and child and have resulted in a number of public interest litigations in the Supreme Court to control commercial surrogacy. The 228th report of the Law Commission of India also recommended prohibiting commercial surrogacy and allowing ethical altruistic(kind,परोपकारी) surrogacy to needy Indian citizens by enacting a suitable legislation.
The Surrogacy (Regulation) Bill, 2016 proposes to regulate surrogacy in India by permitting it as an option for couples who cannot naturally have children, have a lack of other assisted reproductive technology options, are keen to have a biological child, and can find a surrogate mother among their relatives. Altruistic surrogacy, which means an arrangement without transfer of funds as inducement(incentive,प्रलोभन), is currently practised in some centres in India, though the majority of surrogacy centres use women who are paid for their services. The child born through surrogacy will have all the rights of a biological child. Indian infertile couples between the ages of 23-50 years (woman) and 26-55 (man) who have been married for five years and who do not have a surviving child will be eligible for surrogacy. The surrogate mother should be a close relative of the intending couple and between the ages of 25-35 years and shall act as a surrogate mother only once in her lifetime. Implementation will be through the national and State surrogacy boards. Any establishment found undertaking commercial surrogacy, abandoning(leave,छोड़ना) the child, exploiting the surrogate mother, selling or importing a human embryo shall be punishable with imprisonment for a term not be less than 10 years and with a fine up to Rs.10 lakh. Registered surrogacy clinics will have to maintain all records for a minimum period of 25 years.
Think adoption
While infertility is a growing problem in India, there are many different ways of making a family. Adoption is an underutilised option that can not only give happiness to a childless couple but also provide a home and a future for an orphan child. While the Bill will now be placed before Parliament and the details debated, the basic tenet of disallowing commercial surrogacy is at its heart, and will remain.
 courtesy:the hindu

Tuesday, August 30, 2016

The new war on piracy


Recent reports about the change in copyright infringement(violation,उल्लंघन) warnings on various websites have triggered anxiety among many Internet users in India. While the government has maintained a list of banned websites for quite some time, the warning that one earlier saw merely mentioned that the website had been blocked under directions from the Department of Telecommunications, while the new message warns against the viewing, downloading, exhibition and duplication of the contents of the URL as being offences which are punishable under Sections 63, 63-A, 65 and 65-A of the Copyright Act. It further states that these provisions prescribe a punishment of up to three years and a fine of up to Rs.3 lakh.
Conflating various provisions

Sec. 63 of the Copyright Act, which deals with the offence of infringement, provides that any person who ‘knowingly’ infringes copyright or abets
(assist,उकसाना) in the infringement of the same may be punished with imprisonment (minimum of six months and extendable to three years) and fined up to Rs.2 lakh. The new warning seems to have accounted for inflation and arbitrarily(randomly,मनमाने ढंग से )extended the fine amount to Rs.3 lakh, but that is only one part of its disingenuity. What the warning does is to conflate(mix,मिश्रित) all the provisions and flatten them as though they all deal with a singular thing called infringement.
It is important to remember that the provision of the Act itself distinguishes between commercial and personal infringement and it provides that where any infringement has not been made in the course of trade or business, the court may impose a term for less than six months and a fine of less than Rs.5,000. Sec. 63-A deals with repeat offences and provides for a higher fine and imprisonment term for someone who has already been convicted for an offence under Sec. 63. Sec. 65 deals with the possession of plates for the purposes of making infringing copies, a term inherited from print piracy which deals with mass reproductions of material such as bestsellers. And finally Sec. 65-A deals with the circumvention(remedy,उपाय) of technological measures for protecting copyright or what is popularly known as digital rights management with the intention of infringing rights. And even within this provision there are a number of exceptions provided where someone may legitimately circumvent a measure for technological protection.
It is abundantly(richly,बहुतायत से) clear that the warning is neither accurate in law nor entirely honest in its invocation of the penal provisions of the Copyright Act. While it is true that some of these provisions penalise the infringement of copyright, the fact is that the provisions which have been cited(mentioned,उल्लेख) in the warnings all pertain(related,सम्बंधित) to different acts and to different degrees of liability accruing based on the nature of the act, the pecuniary(financial,धन संबंधी)gains, etc. The requirement of knowledge in the case of Sec. 63 and intention in Sec. 65-A establishes a relatively high burden of proof on someone claiming infringement, but the warning seems to shift this burden and creates a presumption that any act with respect to a prohibited URL would necessarily be infringement.
What happens in cases when someone uses file-sharing mechanisms as a way of distributing public domain material? Raj Kapoor’s Awaara, for instance, is available through The Pirate Bay, but it is a film whose term of copyright has expired and may be legitimately downloaded from The Pirate Bay. By flattening the differences between the provisions, the warnings seek to rely on a by-now-well-known strategy of ‘shock and awe’. Just as the global war against terror obfuscated(unclear,अस्पठ) the debate through the rhetoric of shock and awe, the war against piracy relies on a similar strategy that conceals rather than illuminates some of the key questions.
Piracy as a productive force

The question of copyright and the appropriateness of a model that treats intangibles
(untouchable,अमूर्त) as property has been seriously questioned both in terms of its normative basis as well as in terms of its efficacy. Rather than just seeing media piracy as a legal or a moral problem, it would be more accurate to see it as a global pricing problem. High prices for media goods, low incomes, and cheap digital technologies are the main ingredients of global media piracy. Media piracy arises when market failures meet increasingly cheap and improved infrastructures (bandwidth, hardware) of information transmission. Does this pose a problem to owners of copyright? Of course it does, but there is nothing new about that. Every technological advancement starting from the print revolution has transformed the ways we access knowledge and culture and innovations in technology have also been accompanied by innovations in business models. Thus while the introduction of VHS and video cassettes were predicted to be the death of the film industry, what happened instead was the creation of a new business model of home entertainment. In the Indian context, Moser Baer recognised this with their introduction of low-priced DVDs which competed with the pirate markets. So assuming that the desire for low-cost entertainment is not going to disappear, the options are either a rethink of the business models or to rely on penal laws to protect any older business model.
The shift in the nature of the warning seems to suggest that the government and private players have opted for the latter. This may be a short-sighted strategy that misrecognises the role piracy has played not just as a destructive but also as a productive force. Piracy indeed does impose a range of costs on producers and distributors of content, but in developing countries they also act as the main source of access to a wide range of media and knowledge. One good example of this is LibGen, a site which provides access to thousands of pirated books, many of which are not just not available or affordable in India. While this is indeed piracy, if we were to suspend for a moment our legal and moral indignation and ask what other descriptions one could give of LibGen, then as Bodo Balazs — a scholar of piracy studies — provocatively argues, it has been the single greatest knowledge transfer project in the history of humanity.
Not a settled debate

It is also important to understand the dynamics of media markets in emerging markets, and the harms of piracy should not be treated as settled question, but one that needs more debate. Studies have shown that the perceived harms of copyright infringement may be overstated and the presumption that every download equals a lost sale is just not true. In a global comparative study of media piracy in emerging economies it was found that there was no correlation
(connection,सहसंबंध) between the commercial success of a film and the number of times that it had been downloaded, and it was indeed the case that the films which were downloaded the most were also the most successful ones at the box office.
The new warnings and the panic it seeks to create are counterproductive for all parties — consumers, governments and copyright interests — that drive the enforcement agenda, and there is a need to frame the debate within a larger structural understanding of the complex dynamics of the costs imposed by more stringent(strict,सख्त) enforcement of copyright.
The history of technology and cultural production is a contested history in which new technologies disrupt existing power relations, redistribute the means of cultural production and redefine questions of access. The war against piracy addresses only one axis of the debate and as with all wars which are being lost, you hope to win by heightening the rhetorical stakes. Perhaps this ill-informed and misguided set of warnings should be taken not just as a moment in which we panic but one in which we collectively raise larger questions and challenge the logic of stronger penalising of knowledge offences. We are, after all, from the country which produced the most subtle text of literal and moral wars — the Mahabharata — in which Ekalavya, when denied a privileged education, created the first pirated copy of Dronacharya to educate himself. Ekalavya paid a terrible price — the cutting of his thumb — but there are still millions who bleed as a result.


courtesy:the hindu